David Wiener Op-Ed in The Salt Lake Tribune: Quantum computers will be here before we even know it

David Wiener Op-Ed in The Salt Lake Tribune: Quantum computers will be here before we even know it
October 22, 2019 David Wiener

The past few weeks have been momentous for those of us tracking and preparing
for the arrival of quantum supremacy — the tipping point when quantum
computers functionally outperform classical computers. Among their many
capabilities, these machines will have the power to unlock the digital encryption
we use today.

That matters right now. Bad actors and nation states have been harvesting
communications for years knowing that technology will soon allow them to unlock
the secrets encrypted within those messages.

Glenn Gerstell, general counsel for the National Security Agency, addressed the
global stakes in a September New York Times Op-Ed, “Imagine the overwhelming
leverage that the winner would have — such a decryption ability could render the
military capabilities of the loser almost irrelevant and its economy overturned.”

When the chief adviser for the most powerful intelligence organization the world
has ever known publicly cautions that quantum computers will be capable of
shifting the global balance of power, it’s time to start paying attention.
The only truly unknown factor is when quantum supremacy will be achieved.
Estimates vary from five to 20 years, with a loose scientific consensus that
quantum supremacy is at least a decade away. Yet…

Google and NASA claimed they achieved quantum supremacy last month.

A paper authored by a NASA senior research scientist was posted on the federal
agency’s Ames Research Center website (Google and NASA partner in quantum
computer testing) announcing that a quantum processor ran a calculation in 200
seconds that would take Summit, the fastest supercomputer in the world, 10,000
years to perform. To put that in perspective, it would take Summit — a computer
80 million times more powerful than a Macbook Pro — 10 millennia to do what a
nascent quantum computer can do in less than 4 minutes.

Mysteriously, the research paper vanished within hours of its appearance. Neither
Google nor NASA responded to reporter queries and neither has issued so much as
an acknowledgement that the leaked paper exists, let alone contains the truth.
Flatly ignoring what may be the greatest technological achievement in modern
history seems like odd behavior, but not if you consider the stakes.

The major quantum computing players are among the wealthiest, most successful
countries and companies on Earth: Google, IBM, Intel, Alibaba, China, Russia and
the United States. Each is deeply and powerfully incentivized to reach quantum
supremacy first. As Jim Clarke, Intel’s director of quantum hardware said, “This
feels like my generation’s space race.”

China is a notoriously secretive nation whose technological advancements remain
concealed until being sprung, fully realized, upon the world stage. Russia, which,
like China, has invested billions of dollars in quantum technology, remains
steadfastly engaged in the world’s most absurd and determined global
disinformation campaign.

Here in America, bleeding-edge technology is almost always clandestine. For
companies working concurrently on similar technology, secrecy is an essential
component of competition.

Broadcasting too much information about progress gives competitors the
opportunity and motivation to redouble their own efforts.

Considering the players and the stakes surrounding quantum computers, why
would anyone — whether a government or company — tip their hand?

As Gerstell said, “The strategic advantage here would be for one country to
surreptitiously acquire such a capability and maintain it for perhaps several years
or more.”

Therein lies the true endgame — not just quantum supremacy, but quantum
secrecy that can be leveraged indefinitely without notice. The wonder isn’t that the
NASA paper summarily vanished, but that it ever appeared in the first place.
We don’t know when quantum supremacy will be achieved, but one thing seems
certain. It will happen before we even know it.

Download the article in PDF format.